Job Shock Hits Mortgage, Home Stocks
By Jonathan Stempel
NEW YORK (Reuters) - The
U.S. economy's surprising addition of 308,000 jobs in March might
make it more expensive to own a home, industry experts warned
That perception prompted a sell-off in shares of mortgage lenders,
home builders and home improvement retailers.
Job growth suggests a strengthening economy. But higher interest
rates often follow. And the Labor Department (news - web sites)'s
report on job growth triggered a sell-off in U.S. Treasuries.
The yield on the benchmark 10-year note soared to around 4.15
percent from Thursday's 3.89 percent.
Rising Treasury yields often lead to higher lending rates, which
can dampen home demand. This caused shares of mortgage lenders
Washington Mutual Inc. (NYSE:WM - news) and Countrywide Financial
Corp. (NYSE:CFC - news), builders D.R. Horton Inc. (NYSE:DHI -
news) and Pulte Homes Inc. (NYSE:PHM - news), and home improvement
retailers Home Depot Inc.(NYSE:HD - news) and Lowe's Cos.(NYSE:LOW
- news), among others, to fall.
"(Shares) are down because people expect interest rates to
increase," said Eric Fitzwater, senior research analyst at
SNL Financial in Charlottesville, Virginia. "This looks like
it could be a catalyst to start rates higher."
Though the unemployment rate rose to 5.7 percent, the job gains
were triple what economists forecast.
Analysts have forecast that 2004 could be a record year for new
home sales. The average 30-year mortgage rate was just 5.52 percent
last week, mortgage financier Freddie Mac said. And refinancing
demand is high, although it is down 51 percent from its May 2003
peak, the Mortgage Bankers Association said.
Higher borrowing costs might steal some of the thunder.
"The extremely low mortgage rates that we have experienced,
and did not expect, this year are probably not going to be sustained,"
said Michael Carliner, an economist for the National Association
of Home Builders in Washington, D.C.
"Greater employment growth is itself a positive (because
it puts more money in people's pockets) but it will take a little
bit of momentum out of housing demand," he said.
A saving grace for home builders, he said, is they "are still
sitting on a large backlog of unfilled orders."
BANKING ON YOUR HOME
Friday's 5 percent drop in Countrywide shares, which have doubled
in the last year, was notable given Chief Operating Officer Stanford
Kurland's March 9 statement that the company, which also services
$669 billion of mortgages, considered itself "well positioned
to perform in any rate environment."
Countrywide, Fitzwater said, "always says it is ready for
a rise in interest rates and a slowdown in originations. We have
to see how that strategy will play out."
Countrywide was not immediately available for comment.
Jeff Auxier, president of Auxier Asset Management LLC in Lake
Oswego, Oregon, said rising rates might also hurt existing homes'
values. This makes homes less affordable to people who need to
borrow, and hurts homeowners, who borrowed against their homes
to buy other things.
"People have been using their homes as banks by pulling equity
out," said Auxier, who owns Washington Mutual, D.R. Horton
and Home Depot shares. "When money is cheap, the asset value
is inflated. But when money tightens, that asset value corrects."
Among big mortgage lenders, the shares of Wells
Fargo & Co. (NYSE:WFC - news) fell 64 cents, or 1.1 percent,
to close at $56.61; Washington Mutual dropped $1.16, or 2.7 percent,
to $41.63, and Countrywide shares were down $4.79 at $91.25 at
Home builder shares also took a hit, with D.R. Horton
down $1.66, or 4.7 percent, at $33.73; Pulte fell $2.63, or 4.7
percent, to $52.87, and Lennar Corp. (NYSE:LEN - news) declined
$1.94, or 3.6 percent, to $52.22.
Home Depot shares fell 40 cents to $36.68 and Lowe's
shares fell 91 cents to $54.90.
U.S. jobless claims fall by 3,000
30-Year Mortgage Rates Jump
Factories Hire, But Inflation Fears Loom
Foreign central banks dump U.S. agency debt
Fundraising: Democrats debt-free, but still trail GOP
H&R Block Sees Office Traffic Falling
Treasury, IRS shut down tax shelter involving charities
Most Corps. Paid No U.S. Taxes in Late 90s
Rise in Rates Won't Slow Home Buying
Treasuries Rattled by Jobs Revival Fear
US manufacturing grows for 10th month
White House Opposes Bill on Fannie Mae
Treasury had workers study Kerry's tax proposals
U.S. Auto Sales March Higher in March